I’ve developed an aversion towards my phone (and more generally my online behavior) some time after life returned back to normal after the covid lockdowns. While browser extensions like leechblock and distraction free youtube proved a good first step, the real turning point was when, inspired by spending time offline, I participated in the Global Day of Unplugging back in 2024. I printed my train ticket (which does not count as a valid ticket, thank you Deutsche Bahn) and went to an exhibit at Völklinger Hütte near Saarbrücken, Germany. I still remember how strange it felt to leave my phone at home and walk around a city I’d been living in for a couple months. This mix of uneasiness and dependence finally convinced me that it is time to break free and start using a dumbphone.
I have now been using a dumbed down smartphone, sometimes less, sometimes more successfully for over two years. Recently, LineageOS stopped supporting my phone forcing me to switch to e/os, which I took as an opportunity to finally share my setup. This post is not necessarily intended as a complete tutorial, but should rather give some insights into my setup and share some tips and tricks.
My Requirements
Following r/dumbphone it becomes clear that the motivation and requirements for dumbphones are quite diverse. The first step, therefore, is to have a clear idea of the key features one requires in day-to-day life, and what one dislikes about their device or habits. My main motivation was a simple budget friendly way to reduce my screen time, by getting rid of reasons to look at my phone throughout the day. More concretely:
- No addictive apps: social media apps, news, browser, …
- Basic features I rely on: Messaging apps, camera, navigation. Other nice to haves: 2FA, Banking, Email.
- One phone: I don’t want to worry about carrying and charging two devices.
- It should be cheap
I quickly realized that going full dumbphone would require me to have a second phone, while many modern feature phones can be quite pricey and often don’t fulfill all of my requirements. The way forward was to find a way to irreversibly restrict my current smartphone.
Dumbing down my phone
There are many simple quick fixes for dumbing down your phone: Minimal launchers, app timers, screen time goals etc… But, knowing myself, I need something that allows for no loopholes and no ways to override the restriction. To achieve this, I am using the android debug bridge (adb) to (temporarily) remove apps using a computer, which makes the action irreversible just from the phone. It does not require the phone to be rooted and retains the option to re-enable apps for travel or updates.
Degoogling (Optional)
One benefit of dumbphones which doesn’t get much attention is the smaller digital trace they leave behind. To get this benefit from my dumbed down phone, I decided to degoogle my phone by installing a custom ROM. Initially, I used LineageOS with MicroG and have recently switched to e/os, since Lineage dropped support for my phone. Both of them come with no Google services pre-installed.
A welcome side effect of this part of my digital reductionist journey is that I can continue to use my 8 year old phone, while vendor support was dropped 4 years ago.
Initial Setup
If you start fresh, the first step is to install all your required apps. Ideally, before migrating, write up a list so you don’t forget any apps, as it will be more annoying to install apps later. Since the final step will be to remove the browser and the app store, updating and installing new apps will require access to a computer. It is a good idea to login to all apps if necessary, since some rely on a browser for the login. Next, we will remove all unwanted apps.
Remove Unwanted Apps
Using adb we can disable and re-enable apps with a computer and a USB cable without requiring any root access on the phone. Crucially, this includes system apps, but it is less convenient.
System Apps:
For pre-installed system apps, e.g. for the browser and app store, use the following command:
adb shell pm uninstall --user 0 <packagename>
The package name of an app can be looked up in the phone settings or run adb shell pm list packages to display a list of all packages.
Note, that these commands uninstall the applications only for the default user 0 as a system wide uninstall requires root permissions.
They can be easily re-installed:
adb shell pm install-existing <packagename>
Note however, that settings may not persist. If this turns out to be a problem, install alternative apps like f-droid, the aurora store, and any browser. User installed apps can be easily disabled and re-enabled persisting all data and settings.
User Apps:
For user-installed apps, e.g., a browser or alternative app store, use disable:
adb shell pm disable-user --user 0 <packagename>
And to re-enable use:
adb shell pm enable <packagename>
Enjoying the new-found freedom
After disabling the browser and the app store, it is now impossible to get back to the capabilities of a smartphone without access to a computer. Since all steps are easily reversible (with access to a computer), it is possible to re-enable apps as needed, e.g., when travelling. This makes it the perfect setup for me, as I can use a single phone as a dumb daily driver and can still fall back to full functionality if necessary.
Notes, Tips and Tricks
Below I list some general tips, settings and observations I’ve made since running my setup:
- While I don’t want to be notified for all messages, I don’t want to miss calls as they are usually important. For this, I have my phone on vibrate and permanently in Do Not Disturb mode configured with special exceptions for calls. Friends who know this, also use it to sometimes ping me if I am not responding to urgent messages.
- I disabled all notifications on the lock screen, i.e., they only appear after unlocking the device. This avoids that quickly checking the time turns into an avalanche of things to take care of. This setting is also crucial for E2E encryption as notifications on the lock screen render the encryption useless.
- Some time ago WhatsApp included a MetaAi button, so, if you’re using WhatsApp, there seems to be no way around having access to an AI chat bot on your phone.
- Having no browser also means you can’t open links that other people send you. If this is important to you, try a kiosk browser, a reduced browser with no search functionality. The obvious caveat: you can just type out links in a note app and open them yourself, e.g., to your search engine of choice.
- Since you continue using the same physical device, it’s harder to rid yourself of the habit of picking up your phone expecting to be entertained. For me, it was good to stop having my phone in my pocket all the time. I’ve started wearing a (dumb) watch and went back to using an iPod for listening to music, and carry it in my backpack.